Unlikely the Ether made the engine tight,
Questions:
1. Did you fully charge the new battery?, they are never fully charged when you buy them.
What size battery did you get? .... needs to be at least 500CCA
2. If the engine had not run for a long time (more than 12 months) the
oil would have drained off the rings, and open valve seats would have light rust on them and it would have had very low
compression, ie spin over easily, but may not start without ether.
now that it has had a run the rings and valves will be sealing better and it will have much higher compression...... you should not need ether now.
Could be faulty starter, but first check battery voltage and amperage during cranking.
Check voltage at starter and at battery.
if there is more than 2 volts loss in the cables you have a problem.
If it is drawing more than 400Amps you have a problem.
if the battery voltage drops below 10 during cranking, the battery is too small/weak
(Note at 9V the Amps will be up over 300-400, weak batteries cook starter-motors!!!)